Murder is the most unforgiving crime, yet when one looks beyond the death and the motives and reasoning of the murderer, they can begin to understand the truth. The creature in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein is most definitely a murderer, however the creature is an abandoned being, who finds a hard time even understanding what is right and/or wrong. For these two reasons alone, the creature should be considered one of innocence. Sure, it directly and indirectly took the lives of two of Frankenstein’s family, but when a being receives absolute no love or care when they are first born, or created, they are going to be severely different from those who have been nurtured from the start. The creature is one of misery, it was not his choice to be created, and he is living a life of despair and suffering. He even states in his conversation with Victor, “All men hate the wretched: how, then, must I be hated, who am miserable beyond all living things!” Right from the start, Frankenstein referred to his creation in a grotesque manner, and as the creator it is his full responsibility to care for it. If Frankenstein would have loved it and treated it as the living being it is from the start, then his brother and sister would both be alive. Because of its inhumane treatment from the start, the creature was destined to be a murderer. Frankenstein needs to show it how to live in society, and what is acceptable and normal in society, because he knows the being is one of intellect. Instead, Frankenstein is disgusted as what he created and he abandons it. The creature is reflected as a product of cruel society, but more definitely the neglect of his creator. Frankenstein perceived it as this monster of evil, though in reality that is what he has caused it to become in his lack of responsibility. Frankenstein completely hated his creation, even stating: “I had been the author of unalterable evils, and I lived in daily fear lest the monster whom I had created should perpetrate some new wickedness”. Through this quote, it is shown very clearly that Frankenstein does not understand his creation and its real intellect. If he had taken the time to search beyond its “ugly” appearance, it could have established a connection with the beast and led it down the path to a good, moral future. However, the creator chose to abandon his creation, which is morally wrong. “With great power comes great responsibility” is a famous quote that most certainly reflects the error made by Frankenstein. He spent an unordinary amount of time creating his creature, so it is also his time to care and over-see his creature. Though the creature did commit irreversible crimes, he stands innocent since it is the job of the creator to look over his creation. Frankenstein is at fault for the murders, not the creature.
Monday, May 4, 2009
Wednesday, April 29, 2009
Frankenstein letter.
Monday, April 27, 2009
artist statement project 3.
For my final project of New Millennium, I decided to create a colorful booklet of quotes regarding the topic of eating meat. I titled it, “The Great Debate: Or is it?” It features numerous quotes from important and known people in the past and present such as Leonardo DaVinci and Paul McCartney, along with college students that I personally know. The well-known figures all condemn eating meat and their quotes are all related to a non-meat diet, while all the college students I asked are pro-eating meat and they each state their reason for this. The quotes are relatively short and are typed-out and are pasted on colorful sheets of paper.
When I first decided to create a booklet about eating meat, I originally wanted to present a debate about it. I wanted to keep it neutral by providing quotes from famous figures who were both for eating meat and and who were strictly opposed. However, this was much harder than I anticipated since I could not find any quotes from famous figures who spoke out about how eating meat was moral and acceptable; I could only find quotes on the famous condemning it. I then decided to resolve this issue by asking my fellow college students why eating meat is acceptable to them. I know very few vegetarians so I knew this would not be a difficult task. After I received my desired quotes, I was able to create a “semi-debate” where the famous were the vegetarian side, and the college students were certainly the meat-eating side.
I love bright, flashy colors, which is the reason I wanted to construct my project with bright pieces of colored paper. I put it in the form of a booklet, which I believe would be easiest to read and would be the most organized way of presenting the quotes. I am a very visually person, so I decided to type out the quotes and then tape them to the paper.
My booklet answered the guiding questions, “What ought I do? How ought we act?” It is based on the key question of "is it morally acceptable to eat meat?" In our society, there is an ethical dilemma on whether eating meat is morally acceptable or not. Though the majority of the world does indeed follow a carnivorous diet, there are millions who strongly oppose this choice. Many believe that eating a living being for no reason other than pleasure is not morally right.
The main message I have arrived at is that it is far easier to speak out against eating meat than it is to speak for it. Thousands of celebrities and important figures throughout time have stressed a vegetarian diet, yet there are virtually none who have promoted a carnivorous one. This certainly should be an eye-opener that eating meat is not all it is cracked up to be; there is something wrong with it.
This project could be related to a similar one I created in high school. I tend to always use bright colored paper, and for my AP history final class project, I presented a similar booklet that addressed the lifestyles of renaissance women. While this project is much more creative and not nearly as dry, the two booklets are closely related to each other.
I want the audience to know that even though most eat meat themselves, there is a reason that no one majorly voices their opinion to why eating meat is necessary. Thousands of the famous have voiced their choice to go vegetarian, while there are virtually not any who voice their carnivorous diet. They audience will hopefully receive this and think about it. I hope they would ponder on this idea and perhaps lean towards a vegetarian diet.
The strength of this project is most definitely the quotes. Some of the quotes are extremely powerful and really make the audience think. Also I believe the aesthetically pleasing style of the book is a strength as well. Perhaps a weakness would be only seven quotes were taken from college students reflecting their choice to eat meat.
project 3 digital documentation of quotes and text used.
-Maria Parise, 18, student
-Zack Patton, 19, student
-Justin Nowakowski, 19, student
-Earl Rigsby, 19, student
-Julien Robinson, 18, student
-Tessa Konkol, 18, student
-Paul McCartney
-Hippocrates 460-377 BC
"The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated.”
-Mahatma Ghandhi 1869 -1948
“I have from an early age abjured the use of meat, and the time will come when men such as I will look upon the murder of animals as they now look upon the murder of men.”
-Leonardo DaVinci 1452 -1519
-Albert Einstein 1879-1955 Physicist, Nobel Prize winner 1921
-Thomas Edison 1847-1931
-James Froude 1818-1894 (Professor of Modern History, Oxford)
-Kellie Pickler
— Ingrid Newkirk, founder of PETA
— Max Tooley
— Pythagoras, 569 BC-475 BC
— Alice Walker, The Color Purple, 1982
— Theodor Adorno, German philosopher, sociologist
“I know in my soul that to eat a creature who is raised to be eaten, and who never has a chance to be a real being, is unhealthy… You’re just eating misery.”
- Alice Walker, 1944
— Plutarch, 45-125 AD